A question for the ages, which I am probably at least a little late in discussing, and which gets ever more pertinent each time Xenoblade does anything new. With Xenoblade 2 newly introducing MOMO as a guest Blade and redesigning its Pneuma sisters with some nice KOS-MOS like plug suits, I thought this an appropriate time to just pop in and briefly say that the answer is pretty conclusively no. It’s a bit more nuanced than that, yet the answer is still no. Xenosaga is not linked to Xenoblade in any manner as it exists. See, even before bothering with all the licensing hangups or trying to smooth over any of the mechanical differences in their lore and ether systems, we simply have hard calendar dates provided to us, and they are wildly incompatible. Xenosaga takes place five millennia later than Xenoblade does. The Conduit Incident occurs on Klaus’ Earth in 20XX, so somewhere between 2000 and 2099. If we just assume that the Conduit monolith was uncovered in 2001 like it was in A Space Odyssey, then it might have taken less than a decade for Xenoblade’s phase transition accident to occur. Xenosaga, meanwhile occurs in calendar year 4767 TC, which is equivalent to 7277 AD. While that may not seem at first glance to be such an issue as both Zohars were discovered in Kenya during the 20th Century, Xenoblade’s Vector and its teams trace back to the 2000s, while Xenosaga’s versions were born at a date several millennia later. Ergo, they do not exist within the same canon.

What it rather is, is that elements of Xenosaga have been reworked and adapted into Xenoblade’s backstory, but they are different entities in canon and function. It is not a standard, continuous bridging of the two Xeno entries, it is that Xenosaga was too cool to simply let lie and so it has been somewhat translated into Xenoblade. Obviously the first thing to introduce an overlap were the cameo appearances of KOS-MOS and T-ELOS as Blades which got a lot of people wondering; but what wasn’t mentioned ingame, only in the Alrest Records artbook, is that the construction of Xenoblade’s KOS-MOS is still credited to Kevin and Shion of Vector Industries, just as it was in Xenosaga.

KOS-MOS, T-ELOS and MOMO do not exist solely as non-canon crossover Blades, they carry key implications for the lore. Then there’s additionally the radio with the Vector logo on it in Future Redeemed, which really gained attention with its mention of Dimitri and his Salvator faction (localised in English as Saviorites). This does not mean that Xenoblade is continuous with Xenosaga as a prequel, midquel or sequel however, or that these are the Xenosaga instances of the cast themselves. Xenosaga having an Abel, Merkevah and Weltall doesn’t make it continuous with Xenogears, nor does Xenoblade 2’s KOS-MOS having the Zohar eye or its MOMO effectively claiming to utilize phenomenon phase shift make them canonically tied to Xenogears. But what has been indicated through the little bits of information though, is the presence of a Xenoblade version of Vector, Kevin, Shion, KOS-MOS and T-ELOS. Importantly, the newly released MOMO is also branded with the Vector logo, despite her construction in Xenosaga being performed by Joachim Mizrahi while he was not presently associated with Vector, he was running the Mizrahi Cerebral Labs that eventually became the U-TIC Organization. These aren’t just crossover characters with Core Crystals randomly plugged onto their Realian body frames. Shulk, Fiora and Elma didn’t gain this trait when they warped into Alrest after all. KOS-MOS, T-ELOS and MOMO are actual Blades with all that entails. The data and design of KOS-MOS must have had some tangible effect on the bodily manifestation of Pyra, Mythra and their ascended state. Therefore, I wonder if the Xenoblade version of Vector Industries might have been either a subsidy of the Aoidos organisation that had Klaus and Galea researching the Conduit in the Orbital Ring, or they might be a competitor who spear-headed the research into Core Crystals as replacements for human grey matter.

It should also be pointed out that, based on my understanding of the mechanics at least, Xenosaga could not simply be one of the other dimensions shown existing on the other side of the Rift. Xenoblade X Definitive Edition presented its multiversal structure as parallel worlds, not alternate worlds. There were evidently some staples like XCX and mainline both having planet Earth filled with humans who begin the Earthlife Colonisation Project, but we see no evidence that they’re alternate realities or alternate histories in the sense of being mirror images. The worlds do not overlap, they exist side by side. There may be some common universal basis created by Samaar, but souls and events do not repeat between each universe. There’s no alternate reality Klaus or alternate reality Rex, so the fact that Vector Industries, Shion, Kevin, KOS-MOS, T-ELOS, MOMO, Dimitri and his Salvators exist within the backstory of mainline Xenoblade on its 21st century Earth therefore should invalidate the possibility of Xenosaga, as it currently exists, simply being one of the multitude parallel dimensions. If we were to ever see the Xenosaga games return in a modernized form, I would imagine this idea where it could be titled Xenoblade Saga, largely retelling the storyline of these characters with just minor housekeeping adjustments like altering the history so that it fits 20XX, retooling the Zohar into the Conduit, giving Aoidos and the Artifice some presence, etcetera.

Anyway, that’s all I had to say, really. Key concepts and characters from Xenosaga are known to exist in the backstory of Xenoblade. This isn’t a conspiracy, KOS-MOS, T-ELOS and Vector have been recognised as such for quite a while and this deeper lore only gets galvanized further with each new Xenoblade that releases. But based on the fact that we have hard, immutable calendar dates for these two series five and a half millennia apart, there is no secret continuity existing between the two properties. It is an adaptation, an iteration, an homage, it is the Xenoblade Saga.
Leave a Reply